Click to View


1 Abu' Fida, cap. ii.

2 Siratu'r Rasul, pp. 24, 25.

3 Ut supra:

Click to View


Click to View

5 Sir W. Muir,Life of Mahomet, pp. xcvii and 31, 32.

6 Surah XXV., Al Furqan, 6, 7.

7 Surah LXVIII., 15.

8 Surah XLV., 6, 7.


Click to View

10 Vendidad, I., 1, 2, &c.

11 pp. 206, 207.

12 Siratu'r Rasul, p. 139.

13 For the benefit of the curious in such matters we subjoin his account, given in his comment on the verse above quoted: -

Click to View Click to View

14 Against this latter hypothesis, however, must be considered the fact that in Surah LIII An Najm, 13-18, Muhammad clearly asserts that he saw the Sidratu'l Muntaha, which stands in the highest heaven. These verses must refer to this Miraj, and msy be thus rendered : -

''And indeed he (Muhammad) saw him (Gabriel) another time

At the Sidratu'l Muntaha,

Near it is the Paradide or the Hahbitaton,

When what covered the Lotus tree covered it:

The gaze (of Muhammad) glanced not aside nor wandered.

Indeed he saw Borne of the great signs of his Lord."

15 Siratu'r Rasul, pp. 138, 139.

16 Mishkat, pp. 518-20.

17 "The Lotus of the Boundary", so called because even Gabriel must not pass it.

18 pp. 206 sqq.

19 Such as the Qisasu'l Anbiya. the Araisu't Tijan, the Raudatu'l Ahbab, &c.

20 Qisasu'l Anbiya, pp. 337, 338.

21 Perhaps an invention to make him bear comparison with our Lord : cf. Heb. vi. 19, 20.

22 Arta Varif Namak.

23 Ormazd is the later form of Avestic Ahura Mazdao, the Good God of Zoroastrianism.

24 Three courts or Paradise, called in the Avesta Humata ("good thought "), Hukhta ("good word") and Hvarsta ("good deed"). They correspond to the Star Court (Storey of the Stars), Moon Court, and Sun Court respectively.

25 Cap. ci.

26 Vendidad, cap. v.

27 "Testament of Abraham," Rec. A., cap. x.

28 Liber Henoch, capp. xiv, xv, sqq.

29 In the Targum of Jonathan, for example, we are told that the Tree cf Life was 500 uears journey in height ! The Muslims confound this with the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil, which they take to have been the wheat plant. Of it we are told that it presented itself before Adam to tempt him to eat of it. Adam rose to his full height, "500 years journey" to avoid it, but the plant grew and kept on a level with his mouth (Qisas'l Anbiya, p. 17).

30 2 Cor. xii. 2-4.

31 A Muhammadan might add, "If we reject the account of Muhammad's ascension, how can we accept those of Enoch, Elijah, and Christ?" The answer is not far to seek. The historical evidence for Christ's ascension is unquestionable, and we accept the other accounts upon His authority. Moreover, to urge that there can be no genuine coins because there are known to be some spurious ones in circulation is not very logical. There would be no spurious ones if there had not been genuine coins, upon the model of which the latter have been made. Hence the very existence of so many legends of ascensions should lead us a priori to infer that these must be based upon some one or more true accounts of such occurrences. Moreover, as the true coin may be known from the false by it's ring, so a comparison between the biblical narratives (Gen. V.24; 2 Kings ii. 1l, 12 ;'Acts i. 9-11) and those others which we have been dealing with will suffice to show what an immense difference exists between them. For instance, St. Paul tells us of some one who (whether in the body or not he did not know) was "caught up to the third heaven, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter." But the apocryphal "Visio Pauli" states that Paul was the person referred to, and puts in his mouth a long account of what he saw and heard there. The difference is much the same as that which existed between the testimony of a sober historian and the wonderful tales contained in the Arabian Nights.

32 Dr Koelle, Mohammed and Mohammedanism, pp. 246 sqq.

33 Similar passages may be found in Surahs II., IV., XIII., XXXVI., XXXVII., XLVII., LXXXIII., &c.

34 Wine is shown to be meant from the context. Rivers of wine are spoken of in Surah XLVII., 16.

35 Much more graphic pictures of Paradise and its pleasures are given in the Traditions. Vide the Sahih of Bukhari and the Mishkatu'l Masabih on the subject.

36 See Al Kindi's Apology : Sir W. Muir's translation, pp. 79, 80, and notes.

37 "Ahaveshumitho 'nyo 'nyam jighamsanto mahikshitsh Yudhyamanah paramsaktyasvargam yantyaparanmukhah." - Dharmasastra, bk. vii, sl. 89.

38 "Dharmajnah prithivipalas tyaktajivitayodhinah Sastrena nidhanam kale ye gacchantyaparanmukhah Ayam loko 'kshayas tesham." - Nalopakhyanam, ii. 17, 18.

39 Cf. the Armenian Aralezk'h (Ezniq Goghbatsi, 'Eghds Aghandots,' bk. i., pp.94, 95).

40 pp. 81 sqq.

41 Surahs VL, 100,128; XV.,27 ; XXVI.,212; XLI. ,24, 29,&c.

42 Surahs XV, 27 LV., 14.

43 Yesna, X., 4 : 2, 53. If the word were Arabic and from the root , it would be not jinni but janin (like qalil from ). Nor is it derived from jannat, Paradise, for then it would be janni. Moreover, the Jinns have no connexion with Paradise, and are not allowed to enter it.

44 pp. 207, 208.

45 The Fravashis are both spiritual prototypes and guardian angels, protecting Ormazd's creatures. Every such being, whether born or unborn, has fravashi, as have even Ormazd, the Amahaspands and the Izads. The "Grandson of the Waters." the genius who presides over fertility and fecundity, brings the fravashis to their bodies in Yesht VIII., 34.

46 Vendidad, cap. v, lines 25 to 35.

47 ' Or the "Dungeon." This is the nnme of the seventh or lowest story in hell, and of the book kept there, in which the demons write the evil deeds of apostates and infidels (Surah LXXXIII., 7-10).

48 As has been already said, the earth, like hell and heaven, consists of seven stories.

49 Qisasu'l Anbiya, p. 12: see above 195.

50 Araisu'l Majalis, p. 43.

51 That is, Ahriman does not know the future but only the past. His after-knowledge is the of the Greeks (Prometheus contrasted with Epimetheus), and Ormazd ultimately vanquishes him because the latter alone has foreknowledge.

52 Qisasu'l Anbiya, pp. 16, 17.

53 Refutation of Heresies, Book ii.

54 Another tradition mentions the following facts which are of interest as showing the importance of this light. Muhammad said, "God Most High divided that light" (before the creation of the world, for "The first thing that he created was my Light," Qisasu'l Anbiya p.2, vide also p. 282) "into four sections, and He created the Throne" (or Highest Heaven, Al 'Arsh) "out of one section, and from one section He created the Pen, and from one section He created Paradise, and from one section He created the Believers. He again divided these four sections into four other parts. Out of the first, the choicest and most honourable, He created me, who am the Apostle, and from the second part He created Reason and placed it in the Believers' head, and out of the third part He created modesty and placed it in Believers' eyes, and out of the fourth part He created Desire, and placed it in Believers' hearts." (Qisasu'l Anbiya, p.2.)

55 In Persian legend, Vivanhvat is the fifth in descent from Gaya Maretan, the first man (Yasna, IX., 4).

56 Yesht, XIX., 31-38.

57 Literally, "in the form of".

58 pp. 81, 84, and 90, note.

59 Later, however, the contraction is found in the Zoroastrian books.

60 See note p. 205 above.

61 In a place called Misvano Gatus (Vendidad, XIX., 36 ; Yesht, I., 1 Siroza, L, 30 ; II., 30). Vide above, pp.123, 124, 202.

62 Dinkart, pt. II., cap. LXXXI., 5 and 6.

63 Yasna, XLVI., 10.

64 The original text (as published in Bombay) is written in Arabic (Persian) characters. By retranslating the Dari in a few passsges into Pahlavi and then writing the latter in Arabic characters, I think I have proved that the difficulty in understanding the original text consists in the fact that the transcriber into the Arabic character did not know Pahlavi, and confounded with one another the very difficult combinations of letters in that confused current script.

65 It is mentioned by the authors of the Dabistan Mazahib and of the Burhan i Qati, so it must have been lost since their day. We have mentioned its recovery.

66 Kitabu'l Aghani, 16 (quoted by Rodweil, Koran, p. I).

67 In the Sunan of Ibn Majah a tradition is found on the authority of Abu Hurairah, who says that Muhammad said to him in Persian, Shikamat dard? His knowledge of the language foiled to supply the verb mikunad, which is required to complete the sense.

68 The Persian word Kandak (now Kandah) has been adopted into Arabic, and occurs in the Sirat in tile form Khandaq.

69 Other accounts say he was first a Zoroastrian, being a Persian by birth ; he then became a Christian and went to Syria, from which country he was brought to Arabia.

70 The word 'Ajami properly means Persian, though capable of being applied to other foreigners.

71 Vide pp. 215, 216, 217.

Click to View